Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
50 Wing Zings
50 Wing Dings
10 Piece BBQ Spare Ribs
20 Wing Dings
About
Gaetano’s Penny Packer
Welcome to Gaetano’s Penny Packer, where the heart of South Jersey's food scene beats strong! Nestled at 224 Pennypacker Dr, Willingboro, NJ, this gem has established itself as a go-to spot for mouthwatering pizza and unforgettable sandwiches, particularly their renowned cheesesteaks. With a legacy that resonates through customer testimonials, Gaetano’s is a reliable haven for food lovers seeking quality and flavor.
Those who crave a hefty, flavorful cheesesteak need look no further. Diners rave about the generous portions—the "mini" cheesesteaks are anything but mini, packed with meaty goodness that rivals even the best in Philadelphia. The secret? A perfect blend of chopped steak and cheese, lovingly mixed to create a delightful experience in every bite. Reviews from patrons like Alberto S. and Ashlee D. highlight a consistency that keeps them coming back for more, with emphasis on freshness and flavor.
But it’s not just cheesesteaks that shine at Gaetano’s. The extensive menu includes salads and other sandwiches, making it a versatile choice for lunch, dinner, or a casual night out with the family. With a welcoming atmosphere augmented by outdoor seating and moderate noise, Gaetano's is perfect for groups, kids, and anyone looking for a hearty meal in a relaxed environment.
- Delivery and Takeout: Convenient options ensure you can enjoy your favorites from the comfort of home.
- Reservations: Ideal for larger groups; just give them a call at (609) 871-6861.
- On-Site Parking and Bike Parking: Easy access whether you drive or cycle over.
- Catering: Perfect for those special events that demand delicious food.
- Wi-Fi and TV: Enjoy the game while savoring your meal!
While many reviews commend the quality of food, a few have pointed to occasional customer service hiccups. Yet, the overall sentiment remains positive, with loyal patrons like Christopher M. recounting fond experiences of gathering for food before big games. Such stories only add to the charm of Gaetano's, showcasing its role as a beloved community hub.
So, if you're in the Willingboro area or just passing through, make sure to stop by Gaetano’s Penny Packer. With every cheesesteak you try, you'll understand why this spot has carved out a special place in the hearts—and stomachs—of so many.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Reading some of these reviews about the service surprised me. I be been going her for years and years. Never had a bad experience. The cheese steaks are loaded and always made well. The prices are on par with anywhere else you can get a good quality cheesesteak If you want a $5 one with some sort of chopped up mystery meat, find somewhere else to go. I j ”
“ Listen!! I can't not say enough great things about this place. If you are looking for a good, meaty, flavorful cheesesteak.. this is the place for you. The steak is chopped, the cheese is mixed in with the meat & they are HUGE! A "mini" is actually a regular sized cheesesteak. I would put Gaetanos cheesesteaks up against any Philly cheesesteak! Go in & try for yourself ! ”
“ I spent many Sunday's ordering a cheesesteak and onion rings from Gaetano's right before an Eagles game. I'd argue these steaks are some of the best in South Jersey. Onion rings are always hot and greasy, just as I like em. My steaks are smothered in cheese, onions, and mushrooms. The only real downside was the customer service. It would definitely have its off nights from time to time. Aside from that, great place to pick up a cheesesteak on the go. ”
“ My favorite place to order for takeout my favorite are their cheesesteaks but they have some great salads as well. My experience calling to place a order has always been very positive and they have friendly delivery guys .I will continue to order from Gaetano's in Willingboro . ”
